Since Shaner has been in Young Men's, I have had more opportunities to bake. Apparently bribery works well in getting his boys to come to mutual :) This week, we asked one of them what treat he likes the most, and he said he's always loved peanut butter cookies. The first thing that came to my mind was the good old days on the farm when Aunty-X would have freshly-made peanut butter cookies ready when we went out to haul hay. (Her's, of course, were made with none only than Adam's All Natural Peanut Butter). So, I called her up for the recipe. She was very willing to send Mrs. Field's Soft and Chewy Peanut Butter Cookie recipe down to me. I have included Mrs. Field's original recipe below.
The second thing I thought about was Cassie's old recipe. She said that she and her mom used to stuff Rolos in their peanut butter cookies. (And then I think they would cuddle and watch a movie together afterward...) You know me - everything is better with chocolate involved... So I took her idea! I have included some photos of the "extra" steps involved in making these perfect little cookies. A little bit more effort makes a whole lot of difference.
After that, I rolled them in some additional sugar, just to give them a nice sweet crunch on the exterior.
Since all the good peanut butter cookies I've had have the nice criss-cross design, I did not skip that step.
I was worried that the Rolo would melt out all over the place, but no such thing happened! They melted and formed the most beautiful, gooey interior you will ever experience :)
However, because I'm kind of a snacker...I ran out of Rolos before I was completely done! Ha, oops. So again, I added chocolate. This time, in the form of chopped up M&Ms.
You may be wondering why I chopped them up. Well, true to form, Costco has INCREASED the size of the M&Ms that they sell. Not just the bag, but the actual candy. They're humongous! As you can see, they're much larger than even my wedding band!
After rolling the dough into balls, I dipped the tops into the chunks of candy and baked them as is. They turned out looking very rustic. I liked it.
I did not add the additional sugar to these ones, and they actually seemed to have more of a peanut-buttery taste to them, which I enjoyed. Shane, however, is not a huge peanut butter lover. He thought the Rolo-filled cookies were fantastic. And guess what? The tupperware was completely empty when he got home from Young Mens. Success.